Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.
UMW Libraries
Simpson Library | Special Collections

Research Skills for First-Year Seminars (FSEMs)

 

⭐ This section is required for all FSEM students ⭐

Scholarly / Popular

Information from experts is more valuable than information from non-experts. This is one reason why professors ask you to cite scholarly sources, as opposed to popular sources.

What's the difference?

  • Scholarly sources are written by scholars (experts in a certain field of research), and are intended to be read by other scholars.
    • Examples: Journal articles, some books.
  • Popular sources are written by non-experts, and are intended to be read by the general public.
    • Examples: News reports, news analysis, opinion pieces, magazine articles, interviews, photographs, novels, poems, letters, some books.

The most common kind of scholarly source is an article published in a journal (a.k.a. a "scholarly journal" or "academic journal"). Journals are similar to magazines. Like a magazine, a journal is published in issues. Each issue contains articles, and new issues are published periodically. However, journals are scholarly sources and magazines are popular sources.

Most journals are peer-reviewed, which means that, before an article is published in the journal, it is reviewed by other experts, who check the article for errors and suggest improvements. Peer-review is how journals ensure that their articles are high-quality. Magazines are not peer-reviewed. See here for more information about journals and peer review.

Use these guidelines to tell the difference between journals and magazines:

 
Journals
Magazines
Contents

Research results, reviews of research 

Example of a journal article (PDF)

News and general interest articles 

Example of a magazine article (PDF)

Audience Scholars, researchers, professionals General public
Authors Subject experts, faculty, scientists Journalists, freelance writers
Purpose To share research or scholarship To inform, entertain, or elicit an emotional response
Review Process Editorial board, Peer-reviewed (subject experts) Staff editors, not subject experts
Language Specialized terminology or jargon of the field Easily understandable to most readers
References Bibliographies, footnotes, endnotes No bibliographies
Advertisements Few or none Many
Frequency Quarterly or semi-annual Weekly or monthly
Length Tend to be long Tend to be short
Examples journal

 

Video: Popular / Scholarly

Watch this video from the University of Houston Libraries for an overview of the differences between scholarly and popular sources.

Citing popular sources

Is it ever okay to cite a popular source?

Yes, in one particular way: Popular sources can provide evidence for you to analyze.

For example...

  • You're studying the space race in the Cold War, and you need evidence of the ways John F. Kennedy communicated with the American public. So, you cite his famous "We choose to go to the Moon" speech, and analyze what it means.
  • You're studying themes of class conflict in the film Parasite, which was directed and co-written by Bong Joon-ho. You need evidence of Bong's directorial intentions. So, you cite an interview with him, and analyze what it means.
  • You're studying the spread of memes in social media. You need evidence of a well-known meme, so you cite the YouTube video of Rick Astley's "Never Gonna Give You Up" and analyze it in the context of the Rickrolling meme.

When you use a popular source in this way, you're using it as a primary source. Click here for more information about primary sources.